Flat top 20 (by tuning net)
All 20 are NQ vs ES, and every row links to its curve card. Tests 373, 374, 375, 376, 377, 378 passed the tuning gates and were checked OOS/holdout. The rest (tests 381–394) failed a tuning gate, and their curves are display only. 55 of the 56 rows on this page link to a curve.
| Rank | Test | Instrument | Length | Avg trade | PF | WR% | Trades | Net $ | Max DD $ | Config | Top-5 | Result | Curve |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 373 | NQ vs ES | eight months test | $407.07 | 1.81 | 30.5% | 82 | $33,380 | $6,070 | lb3 · 09:30-11:30 · st 60 / tp 150 · BE 1R · ms 1.75 | 45% | OOS −53.85 pts (−$1,077, 34 tr) · HO −66.55 pts (−$1,331, 13 tr) — failed oos_positive, holdout_positive | curve ↓ test 373 |
| 2 | 374 | NQ vs ES | eight months test | $361.74 | 1.70 | 29.3% | 92 | $33,280 | $7,270 | lb3 · 09:30-12:00 · st 60 / tp 150 · BE 1R · ms 1.75 | 45% | OOS −176.35 pts (−$3,527, 39 tr) · HO −127.05 pts (−$2,541, 14 tr) — failed oos_positive, holdout_positive | curve ↓ test 374 |
| 3 | 381 | NQ vs ES | eight months test | $359.23 | 2.05 | 17.6% | 91 | $32,690 | $5,730 | lb3 · 09:30-12:00 · st 40 / tp 200 · BE 1R · ms 1.75 | 61% | failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 61% of net (gate ≤ 50%) — never reached OOS | curve ↓ test 381 |
| 4 | 375 | NQ vs ES | eight months test | $402.50 | 1.48 | 41.2% | 80 | $32,200 | $10,090 | lb3 · 09:30-11:30 · st 100 / tp 150 · BE 1R · ms 1.75 | 46% | OOS +133 pts ($2,660, 34 tr) · HO −6.5 pts (−$130, 13 tr) — failed holdout_positive | curve ↓ test 375 |
| 5 | 376 | NQ vs ES | eight months test | $344.35 | 2.02 | 22.8% | 92 | $31,680 | $5,730 | lb3 · 09:30-12:00 · st 40 / tp 150 · BE 1R · ms 1.75 | 47% | OOS +40.5 pts ($810, 39 tr) · HO −257.05 pts (−$5,141, 14 tr) — failed holdout_positive | curve ↓ test 376 |
| 6 | 377 | NQ vs ES | eight months test | $337.83 | 1.76 | 26.1% | 92 | $31,080 | $7,150 | lb3 · 09:30-12:00 · st 50 / tp 150 · BE 1R · ms 1.75 | 48% | OOS −169.5 pts (−$3,390, 39 tr) · HO −107.05 pts (−$2,141, 14 tr) — failed oos_positive, holdout_positive | curve ↓ test 377 |
| 7 | 378 | NQ vs ES | eight months test | $368.05 | 1.85 | 26.8% | 82 | $30,180 | $6,150 | lb3 · 09:30-11:30 · st 50 / tp 150 · BE 1R · ms 1.75 | 50% | OOS −67 pts (−$1,340, 34 tr) · HO −56.55 pts (−$1,131, 13 tr) — failed oos_positive, holdout_positive | curve ↓ test 378 |
| 8 | 382 | NQ vs ES | eight months test | $328.46 | 1.96 | 18.7% | 91 | $29,890 | $5,730 | lb3 · 09:30-12:00 · st 40 / tp 180 · BE 1R · ms 1.75 | 60% | failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 60% of net (gate ≤ 50%) — never reached OOS | curve ↓ test 382 |
| 9 | 383 | NQ vs ES | eight months test | $506.44 | 1.62 | 22.0% | 59 | $29,880 | $11,610 | lb4 · 09:30-12:00 · st 100 / tp 300 · BE 1R · ms 1.75 | 100% | failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 100% of net (gate ≤ 50%) — never reached OOS | curve ↓ test 383 |
| 10 | 384 | NQ vs ES | eight months test | $325.55 | 1.59 | 22.0% | 91 | $29,625 | $7,270 | lb3 · 09:30-12:00 · st 60 / tp 200 · BE 1R · ms 1.75 | 67% | failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 67% of net (gate ≤ 50%) — never reached OOS | curve ↓ test 384 |
| 11 | 385 | NQ vs ES | eight months test | $323.33 | 1.37 | 40.0% | 90 | $29,100 | $12,100 | lb3 · 09:30-12:00 · st 100 / tp 150 · BE 1R · ms 1.75 | 51% | failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 51% of net (gate ≤ 50%) — never reached OOS | curve ↓ test 385 |
| 12 | 386 | NQ vs ES | eight months test | $353.41 | 2.04 | 23.2% | 82 | $28,980 | $4,910 | lb3 · 09:30-11:30 · st 40 / tp 150 · BE 1R · ms 1.75 | 52% | failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 52% of net (gate ≤ 50%) — never reached OOS | curve ↓ test 386 |
| 13 | 387 | NQ vs ES | eight months test | $324.38 | 1.30 | 34.8% | 89 | $28,870 | $11,715 | lb3 · 09:30-12:00 · st 80 / tp 200 · BE 0R · ms 1.75 | 69% | failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 69% of net (gate ≤ 50%) — never reached OOS | curve ↓ test 387 |
| 14 | 388 | NQ vs ES | eight months test | $312.36 | 1.66 | 19.8% | 91 | $28,425 | $7,070 | lb3 · 09:30-12:00 · st 50 / tp 200 · BE 1R · ms 1.75 | 70% | failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 70% of net (gate ≤ 50%) — never reached OOS | curve ↓ test 388 |
| 15 | 389 | NQ vs ES | eight months test | $343.96 | 1.48 | 35.4% | 82 | $28,205 | $9,690 | lb3 · 09:30-11:30 · st 80 / tp 150 · BE 1R · ms 1.75 | 53% | failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 53% of net (gate ≤ 50%) — never reached OOS | curve ↓ test 389 |
| 16 | 390 | NQ vs ES | eight months test | $345.56 | 2.00 | 17.3% | 81 | $27,990 | $4,910 | lb3 · 09:30-11:30 · st 40 / tp 200 · BE 1R · ms 1.75 | 71% | failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 71% of net (gate ≤ 50%) — never reached OOS | curve ↓ test 390 |
| 17 | 391 | NQ vs ES | eight months test | $306.76 | 1.33 | 41.8% | 91 | $27,915 | $11,500 | lb3 · 09:30-12:00 · st 80 / tp 150 · BE 0R · ms 1.75 | 54% | failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 54% of net (gate ≤ 50%) — never reached OOS | curve ↓ test 391 |
| 18 | 392 | NQ vs ES | eight months test | $342.28 | 1.63 | 22.2% | 81 | $27,725 | $6,070 | lb3 · 09:30-11:30 · st 60 / tp 200 · BE 1R · ms 1.75 | 72% | failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 72% of net (gate ≤ 50%) — never reached OOS | curve ↓ test 392 |
| 19 | 393 | NQ vs ES | eight months test | $298.97 | 1.40 | 34.8% | 92 | $27,505 | $11,300 | lb3 · 09:30-12:00 · st 80 / tp 150 · BE 1R · ms 1.75 | 54% | failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 54% of net (gate ≤ 50%) — never reached OOS | curve ↓ test 393 |
| 20 | 394 | NQ vs ES | eight months test | $297.69 | 1.48 | 23.1% | 91 | $27,090 | $8,910 | lb3 · 09:30-12:00 · st 40 / tp 200 · BE 0R · ms 1.75 | 74% | failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 74% of net (gate ≤ 50%) — never reached OOS | curve ↓ test 394 |
Equity curves · flat top 20 (= NQ↔ES ranks 1–20)
Test 373 · NQ vs ES FAILED OOS + HOLDOUT
flat top 20 rank 1; NQ<->ES rank 1 · lb3 · 09:30–11:30 · stop 60 / target 150 pts · BE 1R · min score 1.75
Shape: rising, choppy (R2 0.77); thirds +1148/+488/-88 pts · tune only: rising, steady (R2 0.93); thirds +316/+1186/+166 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 82 trades, $33,380, PF 1.81, WR 30.5%, max DD $6,070. Passed the tuning gates.
Why it fails: OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) −53.85 pts = −$1,077 on 34 trades, PF 0.95 — negative; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) −66.55 pts = −$1,331 on 13 trades, PF 0.82 — negative. Failed gates: oos_positive, holdout_positive.
Test 374 · NQ vs ES FAILED OOS + HOLDOUT
flat top 20 rank 2; NQ<->ES rank 2 · lb3 · 09:30–12:00 · stop 60 / target 150 pts · BE 1R · min score 1.75
Shape: rising, choppy (R2 0.65); thirds +1326/+306/-271 pts · tune only: rising, steady (R2 0.89); thirds +554/+1004/+105 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 92 trades, $33,280, PF 1.70, WR 29.3%, max DD $7,270. Passed the tuning gates.
Why it fails: OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) −176.35 pts = −$3,527 on 39 trades, PF 0.86 — negative; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) −127.05 pts = −$2,541 on 14 trades, PF 0.70 — negative. Failed gates: oos_positive, holdout_positive.
Test 381 · NQ vs ES FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
flat top 20 rank 3; NQ<->ES rank 3 · lb3 · 09:30–12:00 · stop 40 / target 200 pts · BE 1R · min score 1.75
Shape: rising, choppy (R2 0.75); thirds +1176/+296/+96 pts · tune only: rising, choppy (R2 0.79); thirds +904/+425/+305 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 91 trades, $32,690, PF 2.05, WR 17.6%, max DD $5,730 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 61% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) +140.5 pts = $2,810 on 39 trades, PF 1.16; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) −207.05 pts = −$4,141 on 14 trades, PF 0.49.
Test 375 · NQ vs ES FAILED HOLDOUT
flat top 20 rank 4; NQ<->ES rank 4 · lb3 · 09:30–11:30 · stop 100 / target 150 pts · BE 1R · min score 1.75
Shape: rising, steady (R2 0.87); thirds +728/+879/+129 pts · tune only: rising, steady (R2 0.87); thirds -114/+1086/+637 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 80 trades, $32,200, PF 1.48, WR 41.2%, max DD $10,090. Passed the tuning gates.
Why it fails: OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) +133 pts = $2,660 on 34 trades, PF 1.07 — positive; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) −6.5 pts = −$130 on 13 trades, PF 0.99 — negative. Failed gates: holdout_positive.
Test 376 · NQ vs ES FAILED HOLDOUT
flat top 20 rank 5; NQ<->ES rank 5 · lb3 · 09:30–12:00 · stop 40 / target 150 pts · BE 1R · min score 1.75
Shape: rising, choppy (R2 0.70); thirds +1126/+296/-54 pts · tune only: rising, steady (R2 0.85); thirds +854/+474/+255 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 92 trades, $31,680, PF 2.02, WR 22.8%, max DD $5,730. Passed the tuning gates.
Why it fails: OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) +40.5 pts = $810 on 39 trades, PF 1.05 — positive; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) −257.05 pts = −$5,141 on 14 trades, PF 0.37 — negative. Failed gates: holdout_positive.
Test 377 · NQ vs ES FAILED OOS + HOLDOUT
flat top 20 rank 6; NQ<->ES rank 6 · lb3 · 09:30–12:00 · stop 50 / target 150 pts · BE 1R · min score 1.75
Shape: rising, choppy (R2 0.71); thirds +1076/+276/-74 pts · tune only: rising, steady (R2 0.87); thirds +634/+534/+385 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 92 trades, $31,080, PF 1.76, WR 26.1%, max DD $7,150. Passed the tuning gates.
Why it fails: OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) −169.5 pts = −$3,390 on 39 trades, PF 0.84 — negative; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) −107.05 pts = −$2,141 on 14 trades, PF 0.74 — negative. Failed gates: oos_positive, holdout_positive.
Test 378 · NQ vs ES FAILED OOS + HOLDOUT
flat top 20 rank 7; NQ<->ES rank 7 · lb3 · 09:30–11:30 · stop 50 / target 150 pts · BE 1R · min score 1.75
Shape: rising, steady (R2 0.82); thirds +878/+428/+78 pts · tune only: rising, steady (R2 0.92); thirds +386/+686/+436 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 82 trades, $30,180, PF 1.85, WR 26.8%, max DD $6,150. Passed the tuning gates.
Why it fails: OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) −67 pts = −$1,340 on 34 trades, PF 0.93 — negative; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) −56.55 pts = −$1,131 on 13 trades, PF 0.84 — negative. Failed gates: oos_positive, holdout_positive.
Test 382 · NQ vs ES FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
flat top 20 rank 8; NQ<->ES rank 8 · lb3 · 09:30–12:00 · stop 40 / target 180 pts · BE 1R · min score 1.75
Shape: rising, choppy (R2 0.68); thirds +1156/+176/-24 pts · tune only: rising, steady (R2 0.82); thirds +764/+505/+225 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 91 trades, $29,890, PF 1.96, WR 18.7%, max DD $5,730 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 60% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) +40.5 pts = $810 on 39 trades, PF 1.05; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) −227.05 pts = −$4,541 on 14 trades, PF 0.44.
Test 383 · NQ vs ES FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
flat top 20 rank 9; NQ<->ES rank 9 · lb4 · 09:30–12:00 · stop 100 / target 300 pts · BE 1R · min score 1.75
Shape: rising, erratic (R2 0.11); thirds +906/+183/-1017 pts · tune only: rising, steady (R2 0.91); thirds +114/+990/+390 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 59 trades, $29,880, PF 1.62, WR 22.0%, max DD $11,610 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 100% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) −1,216.5 pts = −$24,330 on 33 trades, PF 0.42; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) −205.5 pts = −$4,110 on 11 trades, PF 0.59.
Test 384 · NQ vs ES FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
flat top 20 rank 10; NQ<->ES rank 10 · lb3 · 09:30–12:00 · stop 60 / target 200 pts · BE 1R · min score 1.75
Shape: rising, choppy (R2 0.47); thirds +1376/-77/-71 pts · tune only: rising, steady (R2 0.84); thirds +544/+1065/-128 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 91 trades, $29,625, PF 1.59, WR 22.0%, max DD $7,270 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 67% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) −226.35 pts = −$4,527 on 39 trades, PF 0.82; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) −27.05 pts = −$541 on 14 trades, PF 0.94.
Test 385 · NQ vs ES FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
flat top 20 rank 11; NQ<->ES rank 11 · lb3 · 09:30–12:00 · stop 100 / target 150 pts · BE 1R · min score 1.75
Shape: rising, choppy (R2 0.77); thirds +726/+726/-174 pts · tune only: rising, steady (R2 0.83); thirds +85/+935/+435 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 90 trades, $29,100, PF 1.37, WR 40.0%, max DD $12,100 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 51% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) −69.5 pts = −$1,390 on 39 trades, PF 0.97; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) −107 pts = −$2,140 on 14 trades, PF 0.85.
Test 386 · NQ vs ES FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
flat top 20 rank 12; NQ<->ES rank 12 · lb3 · 09:30–11:30 · stop 40 / target 150 pts · BE 1R · min score 1.75
Shape: rising, steady (R2 0.82); thirds +948/+338/+68 pts · tune only: rising, steady (R2 0.92); thirds +596/+556/+296 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 82 trades, $28,980, PF 2.04, WR 23.2%, max DD $4,910 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 52% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) +123 pts = $2,460 on 34 trades, PF 1.16; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) −216.55 pts = −$4,331 on 13 trades, PF 0.41.
Test 387 · NQ vs ES FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
flat top 20 rank 13; NQ<->ES rank 13 · lb3 · 09:30–12:00 · stop 80 / target 200 pts · BE 0R · min score 1.75
Shape: rising, choppy (R2 0.71); thirds +877/+643/-144 pts · tune only: rising, steady (R2 0.86); thirds +385/+646/+412 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 89 trades, $28,870, PF 1.30, WR 34.8%, max DD $11,715 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 69% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) −59.5 pts = −$1,190 on 39 trades, PF 0.97; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) −7 pts = −$140 on 14 trades, PF 0.99.
Test 388 · NQ vs ES FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
flat top 20 rank 14; NQ<->ES rank 14 · lb3 · 09:30–12:00 · stop 50 / target 200 pts · BE 1R · min score 1.75
Shape: rising, choppy (R2 0.63); thirds +1226/-7/+126 pts · tune only: rising, steady (R2 0.83); thirds +634/+635/+152 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 91 trades, $28,425, PF 1.66, WR 19.8%, max DD $7,070 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 70% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) −69.5 pts = −$1,390 on 39 trades, PF 0.93; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) −7.05 pts = −$141 on 14 trades, PF 0.98.
Test 389 · NQ vs ES FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
flat top 20 rank 15; NQ<->ES rank 15 · lb3 · 09:30–11:30 · stop 80 / target 150 pts · BE 1R · min score 1.75
Shape: rising, steady (R2 0.93); thirds +840/+708/+18 pts · tune only: rising, steady (R2 0.88); thirds +146/+888/+376 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 82 trades, $28,205, PF 1.48, WR 35.4%, max DD $9,690 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 53% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) +423 pts = $8,460 on 34 trades, PF 1.31; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) −266.5 pts = −$5,330 on 13 trades, PF 0.53.
Test 390 · NQ vs ES FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
flat top 20 rank 16; NQ<->ES rank 16 · lb3 · 09:30–11:30 · stop 40 / target 200 pts · BE 1R · min score 1.75
Shape: rising, steady (R2 0.86); thirds +858/+378/+219 pts · tune only: rising, steady (R2 0.87); thirds +546/+506/+346 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 81 trades, $27,990, PF 2.00, WR 17.3%, max DD $4,910 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 71% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) +223 pts = $4,460 on 34 trades, PF 1.29; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) −166.55 pts = −$3,331 on 13 trades, PF 0.55.
Test 391 · NQ vs ES FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
flat top 20 rank 17; NQ<->ES rank 17 · lb3 · 09:30–12:00 · stop 80 / target 150 pts · BE 0R · min score 1.75
Shape: rising, steady (R2 0.89); thirds +717/+736/+276 pts · tune only: rising, choppy (R2 0.75); thirds +264/+556/+575 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 91 trades, $27,915, PF 1.33, WR 41.8%, max DD $11,500 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 54% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) +540.5 pts = $10,810 on 39 trades, PF 1.29; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) −207 pts = −$4,140 on 14 trades, PF 0.74.
Test 392 · NQ vs ES FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
flat top 20 rank 18; NQ<->ES rank 18 · lb3 · 09:30–11:30 · stop 60 / target 200 pts · BE 1R · min score 1.75
Shape: rising, choppy (R2 0.63); thirds +1098/+105/+112 pts · tune only: rising, steady (R2 0.90); thirds +266/+1186/-67 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 81 trades, $27,725, PF 1.63, WR 22.2%, max DD $6,070 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 72% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) −103.85 pts = −$2,077 on 34 trades, PF 0.91; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) +33.45 pts = $669 on 13 trades, PF 1.09.
Test 393 · NQ vs ES FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
flat top 20 rank 19; NQ<->ES rank 19 · lb3 · 09:30–12:00 · stop 80 / target 150 pts · BE 1R · min score 1.75
Shape: rising, steady (R2 0.88); thirds +977/+536/-144 pts · tune only: rising, steady (R2 0.83); thirds +364/+796/+215 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 92 trades, $27,505, PF 1.40, WR 34.8%, max DD $11,300 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 54% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) +340.5 pts = $6,810 on 39 trades, PF 1.23; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) −347 pts = −$6,940 on 14 trades, PF 0.46.
Test 394 · NQ vs ES FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
flat top 20 rank 20; NQ<->ES rank 20 · lb3 · 09:30–12:00 · stop 40 / target 200 pts · BE 0R · min score 1.75
Shape: rising, choppy (R2 0.41); thirds +1176/-24/-264 pts · tune only: rising, steady (R2 0.82); thirds +664/+705/-15 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 91 trades, $27,090, PF 1.48, WR 23.1%, max DD $8,910 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 74% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) −139.5 pts = −$2,790 on 39 trades, PF 0.90; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) −327 pts = −$6,540 on 14 trades, PF 0.38.
Equity curves · ES↔NQ top 8
Tuning-gate passers: tests 379 and 380 passed the tuning gates, then failed holdout. They sit outside the flat top 20 because ranking is by tuning net in points. The other six ES↔NQ configs failed a tuning gate.
Test 395 · ES vs NQ FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
not in the flat top 20; ES<->NQ rank 1 · lb3 · 09:30–12:00 · stop 25 / target 62.5 pts · BE 0R · min score 1.5
Shape: rising, choppy (R2 0.74); thirds +395/+123/+132 pts · tune only: rising, steady (R2 0.88); thirds +89/+264/+168 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 93 trades, $26,048, PF 1.34, WR 35.5%, max DD $14,392 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 60% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) +109.6 pts = $5,480 on 44 trades, PF 1.14; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) +20.45 pts = $1,022 on 13 trades, PF 1.09.
Test 396 · ES vs NQ FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
not in the flat top 20; ES<->NQ rank 2 · lb3 · 09:30–12:00 · stop 25 / target 75 pts · BE 0R · min score 1.5
Shape: rising, choppy (R2 0.74); thirds +234/+225/+134 pts · tune only: rising, steady (R2 0.90); thirds -35/+265/+256 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 87 trades, $24,278, PF 1.32, WR 31.0%, max DD $14,392 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 77% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) −14 pts = −$700 on 40 trades, PF 0.98; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) +121.15 pts = $6,058 on 11 trades, PF 1.68.
Test 397 · ES vs NQ FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
not in the flat top 20; ES<->NQ rank 3 · lb4 · 09:30–12:00 · stop 10 / target 62.5 pts · BE 0R · min score 1.5
Shape: rising, steady (R2 0.84); thirds +208/+184/+211 pts · tune only: rising, choppy (R2 0.54); thirds +269/+52/+101 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 90 trades, $21,112, PF 1.56, WR 21.1%, max DD $10,348 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 74% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) +138.3 pts = $6,915 on 42 trades, PF 1.39; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) +41.55 pts = $2,078 on 17 trades, PF 1.29.
Test 398 · ES vs NQ FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
not in the flat top 20; ES<->NQ rank 4 · lb3 · 09:30–11:30 · stop 25 / target 62.5 pts · BE 0R · min score 1.5
Shape: rising, choppy (R2 0.66); thirds +321/+163/+172 pts · tune only: rising, steady (R2 0.81); thirds +78/+340/-19 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 84 trades, $19,955, PF 1.28, WR 34.5%, max DD $14,392 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 78% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) +98.15 pts = $4,908 on 41 trades, PF 1.14; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) +158.65 pts = $7,932 on 11 trades, PF 2.04.
Test 399 · ES vs NQ FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
not in the flat top 20; ES<->NQ rank 5 · lb3 · 09:30–11:30 · stop 25 / target 62.5 pts · BE 0R · min score 1.75
Shape: rising, steady (R2 0.91); thirds +312/+216/+338 pts · tune only: rising, choppy (R2 0.80); thirds +204/+142/+46 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 67 trades, $19,628, PF 1.36, WR 35.8%, max DD $13,125 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 79% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) +252.7 pts = $12,635 on 28 trades, PF 1.59; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) +220.8 pts = $11,040 on 12 trades, PF 2.45.
Test 379 · ES vs NQ FAILED HOLDOUT
not in the flat top 20; ES<->NQ rank 6 · tuning-gate passer · lb3 · 09:30–12:00 · stop 15 / target 37.5 pts · BE 1R · min score 1.5
Shape: rising, choppy (R2 0.62); thirds +293/+98/-143 pts · tune only: rising, choppy (R2 0.69); thirds +151/+69/+152 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 115 trades, $18,612, PF 1.48, WR 27.0%, max DD $9,812. Passed the tuning gates.
Why it fails: OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) +17.7 pts = $885 on 53 trades, PF 1.04 — positive; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) −142.35 pts = −$7,118 on 21 trades, PF 0.34 — negative. Failed gates: holdout_positive.
Test 380 · ES vs NQ FAILED HOLDOUT
not in the flat top 20; ES<->NQ rank 7 · tuning-gate passer · lb3 · 09:30–12:00 · stop 12.5 / target 37.5 pts · BE 1R · min score 1.5
Shape: rising, steady (R2 0.91); thirds +240/+165/+12 pts · tune only: rising, steady (R2 0.89); thirds +99/+149/+124 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 117 trades, $18,578, PF 1.59, WR 23.1%, max DD $5,245. Passed the tuning gates.
Why it fails: OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) +127.7 pts = $6,385 on 53 trades, PF 1.36 — positive; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) −82.35 pts = −$4,118 on 21 trades, PF 0.47 — negative. Failed gates: holdout_positive.
Test 400 · ES vs NQ FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
not in the flat top 20; ES<->NQ rank 8 · lb4 · 09:30–10:30 · stop 20 / target 50 pts · BE 0R · min score 1.5
Shape: rising, erratic (R2 0.30); thirds +358/-55/+308 pts · tune only: rising, choppy (R2 0.59); thirds +322/+63/-21 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30): 64 trades, $18,192, PF 1.44, WR 37.5%, max DD $7,810 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 68% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) +170.9 pts = $8,545 on 26 trades, PF 1.52; holdout (six weeks test, Aug–Sep 2026) +76.5 pts = $3,825 on 10 trades, PF 1.63.
Equity curves · GC↔SI top 8
Test 401 · GC vs SI FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
not in the flat top 20; GC<->SI rank 1 · lb4 · 08:20–11:00 · stop 12 / target 60 pts · BE 0R · min score 1.5 · inverted SMT
Shape: rising, choppy (R2 0.64); thirds +254/+43/-29 pts · tune only: rising, choppy (R2 0.42); thirds +221/+9/-63 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30, GC data from 2025-12-31): 51 trades, $16,765, PF 1.34, WR 21.6%, max DD $10,935 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 178% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) +101.15 pts = $10,115 on 45 trades, PF 1.23; holdout: none (SI ends 2026-07-31).
Test 402 · GC vs SI FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
not in the flat top 20; GC<->SI rank 2 · lb3 · 08:20–11:00 · stop 10 / target 45 pts · BE 0R · min score 1.75 · inverted SMT
Shape: rising, choppy (R2 0.42); thirds +190/-19/-19 pts · tune only: rising, choppy (R2 0.60); thirds +157/+47/-52 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30, GC data from 2025-12-31): 50 trades, $15,250, PF 1.40, WR 24.0%, max DD $11,165 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 147% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) −0.7 pts = −$70 on 38 trades, PF 1.00; holdout: none (SI ends 2026-07-31).
Test 403 · GC vs SI FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
not in the flat top 20; GC<->SI rank 3 · lb4 · 08:20–11:00 · stop 8 / target 60 pts · BE 0R · min score 1.5 · inverted SMT
Shape: rising, choppy (R2 0.52); thirds +206/+11/+79 pts · tune only: rising, erratic (R2 0.07); thirds +261/-71/-71 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30, GC data from 2025-12-31): 51 trades, $11,965, PF 1.33, WR 15.7%, max DD $16,555 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 250% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) +177.25 pts = $17,725 on 45 trades, PF 1.59; holdout: none (SI ends 2026-07-31).
Test 404 · GC vs SI FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
not in the flat top 20; GC<->SI rank 4 · lb4 · 08:20–11:00 · stop 10 / target 60 pts · BE 0R · min score 1.5 · inverted SMT
Shape: rising, erratic (R2 0.36); thirds +228/-45/+25 pts · tune only: rising, erratic (R2 0.11); thirds +241/-33/-103 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30, GC data from 2025-12-31): 51 trades, $10,565, PF 1.24, WR 17.6%, max DD $16,555 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 283% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) +103.15 pts = $10,315 on 45 trades, PF 1.27; holdout: none (SI ends 2026-07-31).
Test 405 · GC vs SI FAILED TUNING GATE · TUNE PF
not in the flat top 20; GC<->SI rank 5 · lb3 · 08:20–11:00 · stop 12 / target 45 pts · BE 0R · min score 1.75 · inverted SMT
Shape: rising, erratic (R2 0.09); thirds +104/-67/+47 pts · tune only: rising, erratic (R2 0.35); thirds +135/+21/-80 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30, GC data from 2025-12-31): 50 trades, $7,650, PF 1.17, WR 24.0%, max DD $13,365 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate tune_pf: tune PF 1.17 (gate ≥ 1.2). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) +6.45 pts = $645 on 37 trades, PF 1.02; holdout: none (SI ends 2026-07-31).
Test 406 · GC vs SI FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
not in the flat top 20; GC<->SI rank 6 · lb3 · 08:20–11:00 · stop 8 / target 45 pts · BE 0R · min score 1.75 · inverted SMT
Shape: rising, erratic (R2 0.00); thirds +126/-24/-77 pts · tune only: rising, erratic (R2 0.23); thirds +179/-33/-77 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30, GC data from 2025-12-31): 50 trades, $6,950, PF 1.21, WR 18.0%, max DD $12,225 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 323% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) −44.7 pts = −$4,470 on 38 trades, PF 0.83; holdout: none (SI ends 2026-07-31).
Test 407 · GC vs SI FAILED TUNING GATE · TOP5 SHARE
not in the flat top 20; GC<->SI rank 7 · lb4 · 08:20–11:00 · stop 12 / target 75 pts · BE 1R · min score 1.5 · inverted SMT
Shape: rising, choppy (R2 0.51); thirds +35/+178/-47 pts · tune only: rising, erratic (R2 0.04); thirds +122/-99/+40 pts
Tune (2025-09-10 → 2026-04-30, GC data from 2025-12-31): 50 trades, $6,280, PF 1.20, WR 10.0%, max DD $14,760 = table row (re-run checked on every metric).
Why it fails: failed tuning gate top5_share: top-5 trades 596% of tune net (gate ≤ 50%). It never reached OOS validation. After-tune part of the curve, display only (not validation): OOS (three months test, May–Jul 2026) +104.25 pts = $10,425 on 45 trades, PF 1.39; holdout: none (SI ends 2026-07-31).
Curve withheld · re-run did not match the table
GC vs SI (GC<->SI rank 8) · lb3 · 08:20–11:00 · stop 20 / target 45 · BE 0R · min score 1.75 · table: 50 trades, $5,700. The tune re-run itself matches the table (50 trades, $5,700). But in the one-run curve the last tune trade (entered 2026-04-30) stays open past the tune end and exits on 2026-05-01. So the curve's tune part shows 49 tr 5265.0, not the table's figures. No curve or test number until this is resolved.
































































































































































































































































































































































































































































